<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.0 Transitional//EN">
<HTML><HEAD>
<META http-equiv=Content-Type content="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1">
<META content="MSHTML 5.50.4725.2100" name=GENERATOR></HEAD>
<BODY style="MARGIN-TOP: 2px; FONT: 10pt Arial; MARGIN-LEFT: 2px">
<DIV><STRONG>Recommandation to the European Council introduced by 38 MEPs from 7
political groups, among them 4 former shadow rapporteurs on privacy in the
electronic communications, Christian Von Bötticher (EPP), Elena Ornella Paciotti
(PSE), Sarah Ludford (ELDR), Alima Boumediene-Thiery (Greens) and the
Coordinator of the GUE in the LIBE Committee, Giuseppe Di Lello.</STRONG></DIV>
<DIV> </DIV>
<DIV>In a letter to his collegues to present the initiative, Marco Cappato (MEP,
italian Radical, former EP Rapporteur on privacy in the electronic
communications), wrote:<BR><EM>"(...) Many people are now asking for "data
retention" to become not only possible but obligatory. We invite you to take
action against this potential development. The project known as "Total
Information Awareness" - carried out on behalf of the U.S. administration by
General Poindexter - could well develop into an integrated system of monitoring
and analysis of all types of database (from the use of credit cards to Internet
use) which due to technical needs would extend to a global level. The
European Council is currently discussing proposals aimed at making it obligatory
for telephone and Internet companies to gather personal data relative to the
electronic communication of all citizens. We believe, on the contrary, that it
is opportune and necessary to let the Member States conduct the fight against
crime in other ways, and according to other priorities, perhaps by investing to
strengthen instruments capable of bringing information, knowledge and democracy
to countries ruled by dictatorships (...)</EM></DIV>
<DIV> </DIV>
<DIV><STRONG>The recommandation, that will now be assigned to the competent
Committee:</STRONG> </DIV>
<DIV> </DIV>
<DIV>* recalls to the Council and to the Member States that broad measures
providing for mandatory systematic preventive retention of traffic and location
data concerning citizens' electronic communications for law enforcement purposes
are a violation of art. 8 of the European Court of Human Rights and its
jurisprudence, and are consequently contrary to the relevant EU data protection
directives;<BR>* considers that the general retention of traffic data concerning
all communications and electronic transactions by all citizens for the sole
purpose of providing law enforcement authorities with material for
investigations would seriously risk to undermine the very democracy it claims to
defend;<BR>* considers that less privacy invasive measures such as onward
preservation of traffic data in specific cases are already available and more
suitable to achieve the objectives pursued; The access by law enforcement
authorities to data preserved shall at least: a) require judicial approval based
upon the showing of a demonstrable need and the respect of a high legal standard
of probativeness; b) be strictly limited to those purposes for which the EU law
and the ECHR allow exceptions to the principle of confidentiality of
communications; c) be specific to a transaction or subscriber or user;
data accessed by law enforcement authorities shall not be transferred to
non-member state countries lacking the guarantees (...); <BR>* recommends to the
Council and to Member States to withdraw, abstain from adopting or change any
proposal either at the national, European or international level, that is in
contradiction with the above mentioned principles and provisions.</DIV>
<DIV> </DIV>
<DIV>List of the other signatories:<BR><STRONG>EPP</STRONG>: Francesco Fiori,
Vice-Chairman of the EPP Group; Mario Mauro; Raffaele Costa;
<STRONG>ELDR</STRONG>: Bill Newton Dunn, Elly Ploij-Van Gorsel, Chairman of the
Delegation for relations with the People's Republic of China; Marco Formentini,
Astrid Thors; <STRONG>PSE</STRONG>: Proinsias De Rossa;, Gianni Vattimo, Jacques
F. Poos, Member of the Bureau of the PSE Group; Pasqualina Napoletano,
Vice-Chairman of the PSE Group; Myrsini Zorba, Béatrice Patrie, José Maria
Mendiluce; <STRONG>GUE</STRONG>: Eric Meijer, Member of the Bureau of the GUE
Group; Ole Krarup; Luigi Vinci; Giuseppe Di Lello; <STRONG>V</STRONG>: Daniel
Marc Cohn-Bendit, Co-president of the Greens Group; Raina Mercedes Echerer,
Matti Wuori, Patricia McKenna, Didier Rod, Caroline Lucas, Paul Lannoye;
<STRONG>UEN</STRONG>: Franz Turchi, Vice-Chairman of the committee on Budgets;
<STRONG>NI</STRONG>: Marco Cappato, Gianfranco Dell'Alba, Emma Bonino, Marco
Pannella, Benedetto della Vedova, Maurizio Turco, Olivier Dupuis, Koldo
Gorostiaga</DIV></BODY></HTML>